CorPrecision AIPRECISION MARKETING EXECUTION, AUTOMATED.
Guide/DIY vs. AI Marketing Team

How to Check Whether AI Recommends Your CPA Firm (One Search Is Not Enough)

AI assistants rarely give the same list twice. A self-check for CPA firm owners: what to ask, how many times, and how to count whether AI names you.

Tony PsaromatisNovember 16, 20269 min read
How to Check Whether AI Recommends Your CPA Firm (One Search Is Not Enough)

Chances are you have already typed something into ChatGPT to see whether it knows your firm. Maybe it was the firm's name. Maybe it was "best CPA in" and your city. You got an answer, and you may have wondered since what that answer was worth.

That check is the right instinct. Here is how to turn it into a number you can track from month to month.

Trade press is telling firms to run this check

On October 13, CPA Practice Advisor ran a piece for accounting firms on the move from search engine optimization to generative engine optimization, the work of showing up in AI answers. One section is headed "Test Your Firm's AI Visibility." It tells firms to enter the questions their ideal clients might ask and check whether the firm is mentioned, whether competitors are, and which websites appear as sources. Near the end, the piece gives a 30-minute starting plan: "Test five client-focused questions across AI search platforms," then repeat the assessment monthly with the same questions, "while recognizing that AI results can change between tests" (CPA Practice Advisor). The author is a marketing consultant who works with accounting firms. Three weeks later the same publication ran a second piece that tells firms to look for "trends over time rather than drawing conclusions from a single AI response" (CPA Practice Advisor).

Plenty of owners have already done some version of it. BrightLocal, which sells local search software including a tool that tracks AI visibility, surveyed 1,002 U.S. owners of local businesses with 1 to 50 employees for a report published in October, and 54% said they "have checked and are confident their business appears in AI results" (BrightLocal).

The stakes for a CPA firm are easy to see. An owner who asks an assistant for an accountant gets a handful of firms back. In BrightLocal's study of local AI searches, ChatGPT named about four businesses per answer (BrightLocal).

When an assistant answers with four names, the question worth asking is how often yours is one of them.

What a single answer tells you

Two pieces of research explain why one look is a weak test.

The first comes from SparkToro, published in January. Six hundred volunteers ran 12 prompts through three AI tools, including ChatGPT and Google's AI Overviews, "a combined 2,961 times." The headline finding is that the tools "rarely give the same list of brands or recommendations twice," fewer than 1 time in 100, "no matter the question." Getting the same list in the same order was closer to 1 in 1,000. The authors' conclusion is that "visibility % across dozens to hundreds of prompts run multiple times is a reasonable metric" (SparkToro). Read it with its limits in view. The runs took place in late 2025, none of the prompts asked about accountants, the authors say they are not professional researchers, and one of them works for a company that sells AI tracking, which the post discloses. The lists were also more alike in narrow categories with fewer options, which a CPA search in one city may be.

The second is local, and also from BrightLocal. It ran about 200,000 localized searches on ChatGPT, Google's AI Mode and AI Overviews, for about 1,300 business locations over 60 days. When the same prompt was run again, the two sets of businesses overlapped by 20% to 33% on average, and by 23% for ChatGPT. A business that showed up once came back in about half of the later attempts. In BrightLocal's own words: "If you run a prompt 4 times, a single business is likely to appear in two of those."

The question you pick matters too. I put CorPrecision through the same audit my team runs for firms that request one. It asked 18 questions an owner might type when hiring a marketing agency, once for the United States and once for Greenville, and repeated each one three times on each of ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, for 324 answers. We were named in three. All three answered one question, a narrow one about agencies for a single specialized industry.

A check built on one of those questions, run once, would have told me very little about the other seventeen.

A single answer is one draw from a list that changes almost every time you ask.

A self-check that gives you a number

You can run a smaller version of the full audit with a spreadsheet. Start with how you word the questions. BrightLocal makes the point well: "Finding your business by name is encouraging, but it doesn't tell you whether you appear when someone searches for the service they need without already knowing who you are" (BrightLocal).

  • Write eight to ten questions a business owner would type before they have heard of you. Cover the services you want more of and the clients you serve best: an S corp election, an IRS notice, year-round tax planning, bookkeeping for a new company. Put your city in every question and leave your firm's name out.
  • Ask from a clean session. ChatGPT can use your past conversations to personalize its answers, and a temporary chat set to Unpersonalized "does not use memory, custom instructions, or plugins" (OpenAI). That matters if you have spent months asking it about your own firm.
  • Ask each question three times, in a fresh chat each time.
  • Use at least three assistants, for example ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. They disagree with each other: in BrightLocal's data, the businesses ChatGPT named overlapped with those in Google's AI answers by about 20%.
  • For every answer, record whether your firm is named, which firms are named, and which websites the answer cites.
  • Count. Your number is the share of answers that name your firm. Run the same count for the two or three firms that come up most often.
  • Keep the questions and the grid identical each month, so you compare like with like.

Ten questions, three runs and three assistants give you 90 answers, enough to see whether your firm shows up for some services and drops out for others.

Leave your firm's name out of the questions. The owners you want to reach have not heard it yet.

What to do when the count is low

The count tells you where you stand, and the answers themselves point to the fixes.

Start with the sources, the websites each answer cites. If the same listing sites, review platforms and roundup articles keep appearing as sources for your city and your firm is missing from them, those pages come first. Then make sure the same firm name, street address and phone number appear on every profile and on your own site. Where you never come up for a service you offer or a kind of client you serve, write a page on your site about it, stating what you do and the area you cover. Finally, check that nothing on your website blocks AI crawlers. Our guide to AI visibility walks through each of these, and marketing for CPA firms shows where they fit in a firm's wider marketing.

For Google's own AI answers, Search Console now has a report counting how often your pages show up in Google's AI features (Google), which the October CPA Practice Advisor piece also points to. While you are in Search Console, look at its generative AI setting as well; the case for and against Google's AI-search control explains the tradeoff before you change it.

Assistants pick up changes to the web on their own schedule. Check each fix against the next few months' counts, using the same grid.

Every answer that cites a page you are missing from is pointing at your next fix.

Run the check this week

This week, write your eight to ten questions, pick three assistants, ask each question three times, and put the results in a spreadsheet. Note the firms that come up most and the websites the answers cite. Save the sheet with this month's date. Next month, ask the same questions on the same assistants and set the two counts side by side.

If you would like to see the full version first, my team runs it free for CPA firms and other accounting and tax practices. Our free AI Visibility report takes about 15 to 20 questions, most of them the kind a business owner types before they know your name and three about your firm by name, and puts each one three times to three assistants: ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. That comes to roughly 150 answers for one firm. It counts the answers that name your firm on each assistant, lists the firms named instead and the sites the answers draw on, checks whether your website is open to AI crawlers, and ranks the fixes. A website can request one every 30 days.

If your firm is already full, our post on firms at capacity takes up whether any of this matters yet.

We use cookies and pixels, including Meta's, to measure and target ads. Privacy Policy